| Back to December Ed Reporter |
![]() |
| NUMBER 215 | THE NEWSPAPER OF EDUCATION RIGHTS | DECEMBER 2003 |
| 'Zero Tolerance' Follies Continue Unabated |
A stick figure drawing of a soldier attacking an enemy, a fictional account of a dream, a loan of an asthma inhaler, a set of violent cartoons, and a Korean pencil sharpener all led to severe sanctions for teenage students in October and November under school "zero-tolerance" policies against violence or drugs.
Scott Switzer, 14, of Colts Neck, NJ was suspended for five days from Tinton Falls Middle School for drawing a stick figure of a U.S. Marine shooting at a Taliban fighter. The boy, whose father and stepfather are in the military, described his picture as "patriotic" and "a war scene." (nypost.com, 11-29-03)
In Winona, MN, the school board has refused to make an exception from its zero-tolerance policy to allow middle school students to bring their own unloaded shotguns to school for a state-sponsored Saturday-morning gun-safety course. "It's like teaching a math class without a calculator," said Scott Sabotta, the course instructor. (startribune.com, 10-20-03) Younger children also got in trouble for bringing a picture of a machete to school and for waving a toy gun.
A middle-school principal in Worthington, OH has recommended expulsion of a seventh grader for drawing violent cartoons. A teacher found the drawings of stick figures being shot, stabbed or blown up in a hand-drawn comic book at Perry Middle School. Under the district's zero-tolerance policy, it doesn't matter whether the 12-year-old meant to harm anyone, a spokesman said. Police decided not to file charges. (cleveland.com, 11-7-03) Sumi and Alan Lough have sued the Katy, TX school district for punishing their 13-year-old daughter for using a traditional Korean pencil sharpener. The mother had bought the two-inch folding blade for her daughter's use while visiting her native South Korea. School officials removed the straight-A student as president of the student council and honor society and ordered her to attend a special disciplinary class for seven days, stating that they had no choice but to follow their zero-tolerance policy to the letter. (HoustonChronicle.com, 10-22-03) Rachel Boim, 14, was expelled from Roswell High School near Atlanta for writing a fictional account of a student who falls asleep in class and dreams of killing a teacher. She wrote the story in her personal journal and showed it to a classmate. A teacher noticed, confiscated the story, and turned it over to officials of the school, which has a zero-tolerance policy. Instead of calling her parents to discuss the situation, the school had an armed guard escort the girl out of her classroom. (CNN.com, 10-31-03) In a non-school incident, a 9-year-old boy was arrested at gunpoint and handcuffed for waving a toy gun over his head while sitting on a bench outside a store in the Cleveland, Ohio area. (morningjournal.com, 10-28-03) |